Many business owners and nonprofit leaders believe they know their audience. They assume that because they recognize familiar faces or see the same names in their inbox, they have a strong repeat customer base. But without data to back it up, these assumptions can lead to wasted marketing dollars and missed opportunities.
If you truly want to reach the right people, with the right message, in the right places, it starts with understanding who is already engaging with your business or organization—and who you want to attract.
Start With Your Current Customer Database
The best place to begin identifying your ideal audience is within your existing database. A data-rich customer list can give you insight into who is returning, how often, and what they are spending. Instead of relying on general observations, use tools like Mailchimp, HubSpot, or a CRM to analyze customer behaviors and segment them based on real data.
One simple way to get started? Survey your customers.
A well-designed survey, when linked to a CRM or email marketing platform, can add valuable tags and classifications to each customer profile, allowing you to create segments based on their responses.
Move Beyond Assumptions—Track Actual Behavior
Many business owners “feel” like they see the same customers all the time, but unless you’re tracking purchase behavior, you can’t truly measure your repeat customer rate.
High-level CRM systems track RFM Scores—Recency, Frequency, and Monetary Value:
- Recency: When was their last visit or purchase?
- Frequency: How often do they return?
- Monetary Value: How much have they spent over time?
Understanding these metrics allows you to send highly targeted, cost-effective marketing campaigns:
- If a customer hasn’t visited in 90 days, send them a special return offer to reactivate them.
- If a customer has only purchased once, create an incentive to encourage a second visit.
Reduce Ad Spend by Nurturing Your Database
One of the biggest advantages of a data-rich database is the ability to save on paid advertising costs. Many businesses spend thousands of dollars targeting new customers, when in reality, nurturing existing ones could bring in just as much—if not more—revenue at a lower cost.
By segmenting and intentionally marketing to your database, businesses can save 5-8% of their marketing budget while increasing sales through repeat and loyal customers.
How Nonprofits Can Leverage Data for Growth
For nonprofits, a data-driven approach helps:
- Understand who is engaging with programs and services.
- Identify high-usage vs. low-usage consumers for outreach opportunities.
- Nurture and grow donor relationships by tracking past giving habits.
- Manage volunteer engagement and retention more effectively.
If you’re a nonprofit looking for locally developed software designed specifically to manage consumers, volunteers, and donors, reach out—I’d be happy to connect you.
Build Your Ideal Customer Profiles
Not every business or nonprofit has just one ideal customer. Some organizations have multiple service lines or divisions, each catering to different audiences. That’s where the Perfect People Builder Worksheet comes in.
This worksheet helps you:
- Define multiple buyer profiles based on data, not assumptions
- Identify the biggest challenges and pain points of each audience
- Align your content, messaging, and ads to speak directly to the right people
Niche Down for More Effective Marketing
When you create marketing campaigns, niching down your message is key. One service. One audience. One call to action.
By getting specific about who you are talking to, you can tailor your message, refine your marketing strategy, and increase conversions—without feeling like you’re shouting into the void.
Start Listening and Leveraging Data Now
If you haven’t taken time to analyze your customer database in a while, now is the time. Start asking questions, listen to what your audience needs, and use available technology to build a data-rich profile of your customers, donors, or clients.
You don’t know what you don’t know—but with today’s tools, you can replace guesswork with strategy.
Download the Perfect People Builder Worksheet Here
Want more clarity on your marketing strategy? Book a free 30-minute Meet & Greet to start organizing your next steps.